
This product is a perfect example of a good idea with poor execution. You have a high-quality, high-demand product in a market with few alternatives (there are only two other "all natural" competitors I can think of at the time of this writing), which is done in by bad packaging.
The wipes themselves are great. They are thicker than most of the others I have found, very soft, and generally have a good moisture level to them. I love the fact that they are chlorine-free, and gentle for our baby. The only real downside to the wipes themselves is that there is no real surface texture to them, which can make it harder to clean messes off skin, as they sometimes smear things rather than capture them.
The dispenser they come in is another story. Some combination of the way the wipes overlap each other and they way they are drawn through the lid result in a "dispenser" that spends the majority of its time NOT dispensing. When you pull one wipe through, it is supposed to feed the next one into position so you can keep getting them as needed. In reality, it barely ever does this. If you pull too fast, you lose the feed. If you pull too slow, you lose the feed. If you pull just right... maybe 3 out of 5 times it will work right.
Couple this with the fact that the pop-up lid will not close if there is much more than a sliver of wipe poking through the hole, and the entire upper lid of the container, which attaches so insecurely that it will sometimes detach simply by pulling a wipe through, and you have yourself one horrible combination. Though, maybe they made the top lid pop off easily by design, since you have to remove it so often to re-feed wipes through the hole.
When I am changing a diaper -- especially a dirty one -- I don't want to have to stop what I'm doing to fix a faulty dispenser. I want the wipes to feed one after another. It really is a shame that they dropped the ball on the design, because I do like the wipes. We bought these in bulk from Amazon, which means I have about 10 more boxes of wipes to put up with before switching to something else.
I recommend buying just one container to see if you can put up with the frustration before you buy a case of them.
Get more detail about
Earth's Best TenderCare Chlorine Free Baby Wipes, 80-Count Tub (Case of 12) (960 Wipes).